Skip to content 
For years, health plans competed on networks, premiums, and benefits. Those levers still matter, but they are increasingly commoditized. The real growth engine in today’s market is member experience—and the plans building it intentionally are separating from the pack.
Why Experience Is Now a Growth Strategy
Three forces have converged to make member experience the primary growth lever for health plans.
The first is consumerism. Members now make active choices about coverage during open enrollment, and they research those choices the way they research any major purchase. Reviews, word of mouth, and ratings drive decisions. A bad experience at one member becomes a lost enrollment at five.
The second is regulation. CMS Stars ratings tie reimbursement directly to member experience metrics. A half-star change can shift tens of millions of dollars. This isn’t a marketing function anymore; it’s a revenue function.
The third is retention economics. Acquiring a new member costs a health plan anywhere from several hundred to several thousand dollars. Keeping an existing one costs a fraction of that. When experience improves, voluntary disenrollment drops, and the compounding effect on margin is enormous.
The Experiences That Actually Drive Growth
Plans that grow through experience focus on a small number of high-leverage moments rather than trying to optimize everything at once.
Onboarding. The first ninety days shape whether a member becomes an advocate or a detractor. Plans that invest in proactive welcome journeys, benefit orientation, and early PCP engagement see measurably better retention and quality scores two years later.
Care navigation. When members need care, complexity is the enemy. Plans that simplify finding a provider, understanding coverage, and resolving billing questions create the loyalty that no marketing campaign can buy. This is where most plans still lose members.
Moments of truth. A denied claim. A diagnosis. A loss. These moments define the member’s relationship with the plan forever. Investing in human, empathetic handling of high-stakes moments is one of the highest-ROI experience investments a plan can make.
Annual renewal. Most plans treat renewal as an administrative event. Leading plans treat it as an experience—personalized reviews of the past year, clear explanations of changes, proactive outreach about better-fit plans within the portfolio.
The Operating Model Shift
Growing through experience requires operational changes most health plans haven’t made yet.
Experience has to be owned by someone senior, with authority across marketing, operations, clinical, and digital. It has to be measured in ways that tie to business outcomes—retention, Stars, MLR, net promoter—not just satisfaction scores. And it has to be funded like a growth investment, not a service expense.
Plans still running experience out of the customer service department will find themselves outcompeted by plans running it from the growth office.
The Compounding Effect
The plans treating experience as a growth strategy are building something that compounds year over year. Better experiences drive better retention. Better retention improves margin and Stars. Better Stars fund more investment. More investment fuels better experiences. Once this flywheel starts, it’s extremely hard for competitors to catch up.
Meanwhile, plans still competing primarily on premium are in a price war they cannot win long-term.
The Path Forward
If your health plan wants to grow in the next three to five years, the question isn’t whether to invest in experience. It’s whether to invest intentionally and strategically—or to keep patching friction points while competitors build a fundamentally better product. The growth in this industry is going to the plans that treat members like humans first. Everyone else will be fighting over shrinking margins
